20% Promise (63)
3% Needs Work (9)
321 Reviews Recommended 249 Shows Promise 63 Needs Work 9
Positives sports_esports Gameplay 185palette Graphics 166groups Multiplayer 117lightbulb Originality 104favorite Addictive 104speed Performance 91volume_up Audio 87replay Replayability 84gamepad Controls 76auto_awesome Polish 63update Updates 26menu_book Story 10
Negatives construction Unfinished 61slow_motion_video Unoptimized 9error Errors 7autorenew Idle 5gamepad Bad Controls 4help Confusing 4bug_report Buggy 3touch_app Clicker 2smart_toy Generated Art 1
trophy 2770
Mar 2023 0 post
Recommended
cool fishing game
AudioGameplayPerformance
trophy 2945
Apr 2026 1 post
Shows Promise
No tutorial.
GraphicsGameplayStoryOriginalityPolishUnfinishedConfusing
trophy 305
Aug 2023 0 post
Recommended
Really a fun game, if you like games in the genre of webfishing you will enjoy it! Hoping for more content in the future because so far it looks promising!!! Keep up the good work!
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayability
trophy 595
Mar 2026 0 post
Recommended
Норм
AudioOriginality
trophy 560
Jan 2026 0 post
Recommended
chill unique game with cute world and characters
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityAddictiveReplayability
trophy 775
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
Puddle Pond: Mouse Fishing stands out as a premier example of how to build a successful game within the Source 2 ecosystem. Instead of overscoping, Pomshine Games focused on a highly polished, tight gameplay loop. It serves as an excellent blueprint for independent s&box developers.
GraphicsStoryMultiplayerAddictiveReplayability
trophy 2179
Nov 2025 0 post
Recommended
le epic fishing W game W assets
Graphics
trophy 2873
May 2025 0 post
Needs Work
Cute little fishing game fun minigame for catching the fish
Gameplay
trophy 2010
Apr 2026 4 posts
Shows Promise
nnnnnooooooooooooooooo really no , no progress game
UnfinishedUnoptimizedBad ControlsGenerated ArtBuggy
trophy 9456
Apr 2026 0 post
Shows Promise
cozy
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityPerformanceAddictiveReplayability
trophy 80
Feb 2023 0 post
Recommended
I like it
GraphicsGameplayUnfinished
trophy 725
Feb 2025 0 post
Recommended
Very polished and beatifull gamdemode.
GraphicsAudioGameplayPolish
trophy 2980
Apr 2026 8 posts
Recommended
WOW this is the best fishing game on S& Box. (really) If your making a fishing game please make it of this quality or better this is the standard.
GraphicsAudioGameplayOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayability
trophy 1690
Jan 2023 0 post
Shows Promise
This game looks really good, and with more features and content I think you'll catch me playing this quite regularly. The game runs smooth and the audio is nice on the ears. However, I find it hard to play for very long because there isn't much to do; there are many fish to catch but process feels the same. Chatting with other players helps to fill the void but I'd like to see the game stand more on its own. I think I can confidently say it looks like the developers are on track to make it so, as the game clearly demonstrates passion.
GraphicsAudioPerformanceUpdatesUnfinished
trophy 335
Jun 2024 0 post
Recommended
очень милая и расслабляющая игра
MultiplayerOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayabilityControlsUpdates
trophy 1140
Apr 2026 0 post
Recommended
game feels nice, however there is a lack of events/areas or stuff to do other than fishing, but for a simple vibe and chill game it does what it does right.
GraphicsPerformancePolish
trophy 2831
Aug 2024 0 post
Recommended
Looks good and plays nice, but it needs more activities.
GraphicsPolishControlsUnfinished
trophy 1081
Aug 2022 2 posts
Recommended
cute
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerPerformancePolishAddictiveControls
trophy 2195
Jul 2022 9 posts
Recommended
крысарыба
GraphicsAudioGameplayStory
trophy 1580
Aug 2022 3 posts
Recommended
Great fishing game, with more content and polish it will be №1 fishing game!!!
GraphicsAudioGameplayReplayabilityControls
trophy 1385
Feb 2026 16 posts
Shows Promise
great game prob the best game on sandbox and its just fishing, would love if they added more polish on graphics and background stuff
GameplayAddictiveReplayability
trophy 230
Jul 2022 0 post
Recommended
One of the best game since launch
GameplayPolishAddictiveControls
trophy 1885
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
beautiful game, could not recommend it more
GraphicsAudioGameplayOriginalityPerformancePolish
trophy 783
Jul 2024 0 post
Recommended
Adorable
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityAddictive
trophy 3060
Nov 2021 6 posts
Recommended
chill out
GraphicsAudioGameplayPerformanceReplayability
trophy 2650
Jul 2022 0 post
Recommended
A very nice cosy game with in my opinion the best and simplest fishing mechanics I've played Also it's not too grindy you don't have a shit ton of stuff to unlock that cost crazy amount of money The artstyle is nice but it lacks cohesion between the environment and the characters, a more stylised shading would look really nice The movements are okay though we can very easily slide on grounds that are slightly too steep and get stuck in some places Looking forward the updates
GraphicsAudioGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityAddictiveControlsUpdates
trophy 1381
Apr 2026 0 post
Recommended
this is amazing. love the environment. I CANT STOP i actually love this
GraphicsAudioGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityPerformanceAddictiveReplayability
trophy 65
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
I really enjoy this title!! This is my first experience with the user generated games so all things considered it already seems like a finished game! lol. I really hope the author continues to work on this for a good while cause I intend to play just as long! While there isn't a lot of content (yet!) I understand the game (and s&box) as a whole is still in it's infancy. Just makes me all the more excited to see how this game grows! All the descriptions, especially the rod upgrades have genuinley funny writing and that really stands out for me. Another being the fishing minigame itself! In my eyes its an ingenous and really fun way to keep it engaging, having different types of inputs like holds, double taps, and especially the timing ones really keeps it alive for me. If you've ever played Webfishing or really enjoy fishing in Animal Crossing. This is your game!
GraphicsAudioGameplayMultiplayerPerformance
trophy 3370
Dec 2024 1 post
Shows Promise
good game but no achievements and i dont want to be a girl mouse child
GraphicsGameplayPerformanceAddictiveUnfinished
trophy 300
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
Its such a great game and honestly addicting, the art style is so cute and i enjoy the customization. Overall it's super fun and i play it all the time
GraphicsAudioGameplayStoryMultiplayerOriginalityPerformanceAddictiveReplayabilityControlsUpdatesUnfinished