20% Promise (67)
3% Needs Work (11)
338 Reviews Recommended 260 Shows Promise 67 Needs Work 11
Positives sports_esports Gameplay 199palette Graphics 179groups Multiplayer 123lightbulb Originality 115favorite Addictive 114speed Performance 101volume_up Audio 98replay Replayability 93gamepad Controls 83auto_awesome Polish 72update Updates 29menu_book Story 14
Negatives construction Unfinished 65slow_motion_video Unoptimized 12error Errors 11help Confusing 5autorenew Idle 5gamepad Bad Controls 4bug_report Buggy 4touch_app Clicker 2smart_toy Generated Art 1
trophy 390
Jun 2023 1 post
Recommended
an actual good fishing game, good job. the weather system also top notch,
GraphicsAudioOriginalityPolish
trophy 1680
Jul 2023 0 post
Recommended
Probably like 1 of the 3 only good games on this platform. Cute art style and although I'm not furry enough or have enough estrogen flowing through my body to play this, I can still appreciate a well made game!
AudioGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayabilityControls
trophy 5870
Feb 2026 3 posts
Shows Promise
Main issue I had was the lack of tutorial. Like my first cast instantly got hit by red and blue keys, then the random yellow later on. It just sucks to lose fish because of random mechanics. Other than that, this is a more engaging fishing mechanic than the others I've tried on here so far.
GraphicsAudioGameplayConfusing
trophy 45
Apr 2026 0 post
Needs Work
Textures bug with chat and text from npcs ):
GraphicsAudioGameplayMultiplayerPerformanceUnfinishedErrors
trophy 1933
Apr 2026 3 posts
Recommended
cute cozy game but looks kinda unfisnished
GraphicsGameplayPerformanceReplayabilityUnfinished
trophy 2753
Jul 2024 0 post
Recommended
I'm not an audience for such games, but I can't help but note that it's made really cool and cute, thank you!
GraphicsGameplayOriginalityPerformanceUnfinished
trophy 1805
Jun 2025 0 post
Recommended
Amazaing little gem of a game, one of the first things i return to in S&Box Hoping to see more features show up, a mission/Quest board for special fish would be amazing :3
GameplayPerformancePolishAddictive
trophy 1297
Nov 2022 0 post
Recommended
One of the best fishing games I've ever played, 7/10 but only because it needs more content. 10/10 otherwise. amazing polish, great graphics and funny fish names. I really like the design of it all it is very charming.
GraphicsGameplayOriginalityPolishAddictiveControls
trophy 1385
Oct 2022 0 post
Recommended
this game is super addictive, the very first time I played, i got completely hooked and now i play every single day i've already unlocked all the fish and now i'm waiting for updates i love everything about it - the style, the concept, the music. big respect to the dev!💌
GraphicsAudioGameplayStoryMultiplayerOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayabilityControls
trophy 2175
Mar 2026 0 post
Recommended
Great game, but got an error when changing appearance : 06:59:47 -7.338352E-05% is not valid with top [:0]
GraphicsAudioGameplayStoryMultiplayerOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayabilityControlsUpdates
trophy 2086
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
The only one game i really like on here
GraphicsAudioGameplayPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayabilityControls
trophy 15
Jan 2025 0 post
Needs Work
not even working, just getting error "gameinstance load failed"
UnoptimizedErrors
trophy 1335
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
BIG AND SHINY. love fishing. cute game. cant wait for future updates
GraphicsAudioGameplayStoryMultiplayerOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayabilityUpdates
trophy 1093
Sep 2022 0 post
Shows Promise
Honestly this is what S&Box should be for, if more and more things like this get created over the typical incremental/slop kind of games that you'd see on roblox/fornite then I have hope for S&Box yet. Still bare bones but would love to see more mechanics, cosmetics and just in general having a fun chill fishing game with friends
GameplayMultiplayerOriginalityAddictiveReplayability
trophy 3775
Mar 2026 0 post
Shows Promise
*EDIT* IDk why but now everytime i play it crashes S&Box please update soon I want to start off by saying I highly recomend this game, I know I have promising selected but I do not want to lure anyone away with that selection. The reason behind the promising choice even though I highly recommend this game is because even though its sights are beautiful, the ambience is amazing, the controls of the game are unique, the leaderboards so you can see who is doing what and strive to be the best fisher, sorry started to lose track with all the compliments I could give this game. It's at the promising selection for me because even though its already a great game you can tell it's still in early stage. But don't let that scare you off becuase this game has so much to do and admire even though it is still in its early stage. I personally can not wait to see the finished product. This is going to be one of the most polished, beautiful, and fun games in sanbox. Mark my words! Highly Recommend
GraphicsAudioGameplayOriginalityPolishAddictiveReplayabilityControlsUnoptimizedErrorsBuggy
trophy 2695
Apr 2026 0 post
Shows Promise
Seems good but keeps crashing for me.
GraphicsGameplayUnoptimizedErrors
trophy 10
Jun 2026 0 post
Recommended
Прикольная нашная игра со своим стилем
GraphicsAudioOriginalityUnfinished
trophy 3813
Mar 2023 0 post
Recommended
cool fishing game
AudioGameplayPerformance
trophy 3040
Apr 2026 1 post
Shows Promise
No tutorial.
GraphicsGameplayStoryOriginalityPolishUnfinishedConfusing
trophy 355
Aug 2023 0 post
Recommended
Really a fun game, if you like games in the genre of webfishing you will enjoy it! Hoping for more content in the future because so far it looks promising!!! Keep up the good work!
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayability
trophy 605
Mar 2026 0 post
Recommended
Норм
AudioOriginality
trophy 1485
Jan 2026 0 post
Recommended
chill unique game with cute world and characters
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityAddictiveReplayability
trophy 1040
May 2026 0 post
Recommended
Puddle Pond: Mouse Fishing stands out as a premier example of how to build a successful game within the Source 2 ecosystem. Instead of overscoping, Pomshine Games focused on a highly polished, tight gameplay loop. It serves as an excellent blueprint for independent s&box developers.
GraphicsStoryMultiplayerAddictiveReplayability
trophy 2204
Nov 2025 0 post
Recommended
le epic fishing W game W assets
Graphics
trophy 4143
May 2025 0 post
Needs Work
Cute little fishing game fun minigame for catching the fish
Gameplay
trophy 2010
Apr 2026 4 posts
Shows Promise
nnnnnooooooooooooooooo really no , no progress game
UnfinishedUnoptimizedBad ControlsGenerated ArtBuggy
trophy 9936
Apr 2026 0 post
Shows Promise
cozy
GraphicsGameplayMultiplayerOriginalityPerformanceAddictiveReplayability
trophy 80
Feb 2023 0 post
Recommended
I like it
GraphicsGameplayUnfinished
trophy 725
Feb 2025 0 post
Recommended
Very polished and beatifull gamdemode.
GraphicsAudioGameplayPolish
trophy 3610
Apr 2026 8 posts
Recommended
WOW this is the best fishing game on S& Box. (really) If your making a fishing game please make it of this quality or better this is the standard.
GraphicsAudioGameplayOriginalityPerformancePolishAddictiveReplayability