Moving on from s&box + standalone licensing

Started by AReallyLongName XxX · 27 days ago · 23 replies · 1,487 views

edited 27 days ago#1
AReallyLongName XxX
Member
JoinedDec 2022 Posts11 Score670
I think I've got about 6000-6500 hours in the engine. It's not an accurate reflection of what I should have achieved but it was a decent run and I learned a lot anyway. 

I've got a few serious long term projects, one of which is a boomer shooter that has been in development since about 2022-2023. I chose s&box because it was new back then, was changing a lot, and it was exciting. And I was familiar with Source. 

I have made some serious progress on my projects lately and I can see them being positioned on a storefront like Steam. That has led to the feeling of sunk-cost fallacy and I'm starting to feel a bit dumb. 

There are some things on my mind:

1) The platform is going nowhere, regardless of what I build. I'm not too fussed about this because it's clear the platform is a structure for rapidly-prototyped minigames, easy to jump in and out of. This isn't the reason I got involved and I just want to clarify that I always got into this engine as a way to make my own long-term larger projects that I could publish on Steam. So my projects are not really suited for this kind of platform or audience anyway - even if it is failing. But still, it definitely doesn't look good, and takes a lot of confidence away that I have in the company building all this. 

2) There is still no concrete official statement about self-publishing. This is the main reason my review on Steam switched over from recommended to not recommended. This really needs to be clarified and is the reason I'm making this last-ditch post to bitch about it. When can we expect an official statement that isn't "ask us first"? Really with the way the platform is headed I think focusing on engine use and licencing is FP's best bet. If you are serious about opening this up, everybody needs to know where they stand. 

3) Games are now greenlit before entering the playfund. This is a blessing and a curse. I'm already very aware of the nepotism that is in this community and the favouring of close mates or community members is not unheard of. But I also think that's fairly normal in these kinds of smaller communities. Regardless there is no clear process established yet that goes over any of these to instill confidence against inherent bias. There's also no clear rules on what's allowed and what isn't. It all seems discretionary. Does Facepunch handle the greenlight decision? Is it handled by the community? Votes? We all saw how that worked with the jam. 

4) For exporting your game, this discretion goes even further. Firstly, you have to contact garry via email to submit your game that you already paid to put up on Steam. Then, they have to contact Valve to approve the licence. This seems fairly reasonable (albeit backwards, shouldn't you approve before I pay to stick it on Steam?) until you realise that the games currently on Steam made in s&box are still waiting for release or greenlight with no movement there. Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong, but I cannot find any information on what kind of response these teams have had. It all seems like radio silence or ambiguity. Are there any movements there? Does anybody know what is or isn't allowed? What is the process involved and is there a checklist?

5) The engine is perpetually touted as "royalty free" which is really redundant if you've got extra hoops to jump through to get your game on Steam. I'd rather pay you royalties than have the ambiguity while I'm working. Cross my toes and hope it gets approved? Why would I do that? 

To be clear I have never been a victim of game-breaking updates or API changes. I've always kept my code fairly agnostic and never really tried to do overly weird shit with the engine. So I'm not complaining about that. I'm also not bothered about politics or discourse.

I'm just wondering why people who are making larger games with small teams shouldn't jump ship to another engine. What motivation is there to stick around exactly? I'm putting all this work in but there's no guarantee a) it'd be greenlit and b) I'd get to publish on Steam. This makes larger projects untenable, but now I'm in too deep, because I thought after 3-4 years you'd have something more than "send us an email and we'll figure it out". 

Maybe I'm overthinking this and should just start porting over to Unity anyway. I'm writing this out because it's frustrating. But something's gotta give. I'm putting way too many hours into something that looks like it's falling to bits. If you gave us actual steps and processes, requirements, or things that are or aren't allowed, maybe I wouldn't be so keen to jump ship, but it all looks so grim, and with Unity 7 round the corner, what's the point?

Basically I feel like I'm stuck in Limbo and I've also read the same frustrations elsewhere. Am I in the minority? 
edited 27 days ago#2
Lime1
Member
JoinedMay 2026 Posts41 Score14,691
Hard agree with this.

People keep asking why s&box is filled with slop and tech demos instead of serious, polished games, but the answer is right in front of us.

Everything about the platform seems to push serious developers away. The last-minute Game Jam voting changes, the vague (or practically nonexistent) process for publishing standalone games on Steam, and now even PlayFund approvals seem to be based on vibes rather than clear rules.
What kind of message does that send to a developer or studio considering investing thousands of hours and actual money into a project?

Why would anyone take that risk when the rules can change overnight and there's no guarantee they'll even be allowed to publish their game?

You can't expect serious studios to commit to your engine while giving them absolutely no certainty about their future on it. Then wonder why the platform is mostly filled with quick minigames and tech demos.

edited:
Me likey minigames tho 😏
Skipin
Member
JoinedOct 2021 Posts96 Score1,432
I think I've got about 6000-6500 hours in the engine. It's not an accurate reflection of what I should have achieved but it was a decent run and I learned a lot anyway.  I've got a few serious long term projects, one of which is a boomer shooter that has been in development since about 2022-2023. I chose s&box because it was new back then, was changing a lot, and it was exciting. And I was familiar with Source.  I have made some serious progress on my projects lately and I can see them being positioned on a storefront like Steam. That has led to the feeling of sunk-cost fallacy and I'm starting to feel a bit dumb.  There are some things on my mind: 1) The platform is going nowhere, regardless of what I build. I'm not too fussed about this because it's clear the platform is a structure for rapidly-prototyped minigames, easy to jump in and out of. This isn't the reason I got involved and I just want to clarify that I always got into this engine as a way to make my own long-term larger projects that I could publish on Steam. So my projects are not really suited for this kind of platform or audience anyway - even if it is failing. But still, it definitely doesn't look good, and takes a lot of confidence away that I have in the company building all this.  2) There is still no concrete official statement about self-publishing. This is the main reason my review on Steam switched over from recommended to not recommended. This really needs to be clarified and is the reason I'm making this last-ditch post to bitch about it. When can we expect an official statement that isn't "ask us first"? Really with the way the platform is headed I think focusing on engine use and licencing is FP's best bet. If you are serious about opening this up, everybody needs to know where they stand.  3) Games are now greenlit before entering the playfund. This is a blessing and a curse. I'm already very aware of the nepotism that is in this community and the favouring of close mates or community members is not unheard of. But I also think that's fairly normal in these kinds of smaller communities. Regardless there is no clear process established yet that goes over any of these to instill confidence against inherent bias. There's also no clear rules on what's allowed and what isn't. It all seems discretionary. Does Facepunch handle the greenlight decision? Is it handled by the community? Votes? We all saw how that worked with the jam.  4) For exporting your game, this discretion goes even further. Firstly, you have to contact garry via email to submit your game that you already paid to put up on Steam. Then, they have to contact Valve to approve the licence. This seems fairly reasonable (albeit backwards, shouldn't you approve before I pay to stick it on Steam?) until you realise that the games currently on Steam made in s&box are still waiting for release or greenlight with no movement there. Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong, but I cannot find any information on what kind of response these teams have had. It all seems like radio silence or ambiguity. Are there any movements there? Does anybody know what is or isn't allowed? What is the process involved and is there a checklist? 5) The engine is perpetually touted as "royalty free" which is really redundant if you've got extra hoops to jump through to get your game on Steam. I'd rather pay you royalties than have the ambiguity while I'm working. Cross my toes and hope it gets approved? Why would I do that?  To be clear I have never been a victim of game-breaking updates or API changes. I've always kept my code fairly agnostic and never really tried to do overly weird shit with the engine. So I'm not complaining about that. I'm also not bothered about politics or discourse. I'm just wondering why people who are making larger games with small teams shouldn't jump ship to another engine. What motivation is there to stick around exactly? I'm putting all this work in but there's no guarantee a) it'd be greenlit and b) I'd get to publish on Steam. This makes larger projects untenable, but now I'm in too deep, because I thought after 3-4 years you'd have something more than "send us an email and we'll figure it out".  Maybe I'm overthinking this and should just start porting over to Unity anyway. I'm writing this out because it's frustrating. But something's gotta give. I'm putting way too many hours into something that looks like it's falling to bits. If you gave us actual steps and processes, requirements, or things that are or aren't allowed, maybe I wouldn't be so keen to jump ship, but it all looks so grim, and with Unity 7 round the corner, what's the point? Basically I feel like I'm stuck in Limbo and I've also read the same frustrations elsewhere. Am I in the minority? 
I had a same experience, that’s precisely why I created my own opensource fork of S&box. I didn’t want to lose 3,000 hours of experience just because S&box is supposedly "only an experiment" plus, I tried out other engines and didn’t like them
GitHub
GitHub - somethink000/Rinten-Engine: Rinten Engine - game engine
Rinten Engine - game engine. Contribute to somethink000/Rinten-Engine development by creating an account on GitHub.
neyeko
Member
JoinedFeb 2025 Posts5 Score1,670
Sorry, I’m not very familiar with the process of publishing games created using the Source 2 engine via S&box—do you have to reach out to Facepunch first before going to Steam, or how does it work? It all sounds a bit vague and strange at the moment. Thanks in advance for any clarification!
Skipin
Member
JoinedOct 2021 Posts96 Score1,432
Sorry, I’m not very familiar with the process of publishing games created using the Source 2 engine via S&box—do you have to reach out to Facepunch first before going to Steam, or how does it work? It all sounds a bit vague and strange at the moment. Thanks in advance for any clarification!
https://sbox.game/dev/doc/exporting/   First, you need to send it to Garry, he’ll decide if your game is good enough to be submitted to Valve, and then Valve will decide if it’s good enough to use Source 2.
neyeko
Member
JoinedFeb 2025 Posts5 Score1,670
This is truly disheartening, as many projects will sooner or later want to expand beyond internal distribution to a global scale. They will end up dependent on an unpredictable factor, and eventually, they’ll likely steer clear of s&box altogether—simply because of that uncertainty and the desire to avoid the endless task of porting their work to other game engines.
SLOW DOWN!!
Member
JoinedJan 2025 Posts40 Score8,036
Just my opinion, but I don't think a lot of videogames are particularly successful and it's to the degree you shouldn't realistically be worried about these things.
If you happened to actually make the next Meccha Chameleon or Lethal Company or Balatro or whatever it's success would easily allow it to clear the hurdles the original post is concerned about. If your indie game never gets that kind of attention then like... I don't know what you are expecting from uploading to steam. Anything you could get from uploading to steam isn't going to be overly worthwhile. I'm not being mean here, my point is it's common knowledge most games bomb, objectively speaking. Unless you have a following on another site, this is probably one of the better platforms for just get a few strangers to play your work and send feedback.

Also I THINK you are allowed to upload a standalone executable version of your games to places like itch but you would need to double check that. Maybe only if it's for free or something IDK but like I said most games (in general, not just on sbox) aren't going to worth your time to make if it's just for monetary reasons anyways so who cares lol
edited 26 days ago#8
AReallyLongName XxX
Member
JoinedDec 2022 Posts11 Score670
 Why do you automatically think I want money? I don't care about money. I want my game to have reach and for people to play it. This platform and engine has everything but reach. They have haemorrhaged players. If I can't get an audience on sbox cuz nobody is on it then I've got no choice but to stick it on Steam (or itch). Goes against the motto. If you ever need a reality check please go to https://sboxdb.dev/
Just my opinion, but I don't think a lot of videogames are particularly successful and it's to the degree you shouldn't realistically be worried about these things. If you happened to actually make the next Meccha Chameleon or Lethal Company or Balatro or whatever it's success would easily allow it to clear the hurdles the original post is concerned about. If your indie game never gets that kind of attention then like... I don't know what you are expecting from uploading to steam. Anything you could get from uploading to steam isn't going to be overly worthwhile. I'm not being mean here, my point is it's common knowledge most games bomb, objectively speaking. Unless you have a following on another site, this is probably one of the better platforms for just get a few strangers to play your work and send feedback. Also I THINK you are allowed to upload a standalone executable version of your games to places like itch but you would need to double check that. Maybe only if it's for free or something IDK but like I said most games (in general, not just on sbox) aren't going to worth your time to make if it's just for monetary reasons anyways so who cares lol
SLOW DOWN!!
Member
JoinedJan 2025 Posts40 Score8,036
 Why do you automatically think I want money? I don't care about money. I want my game to have reach and for people to play it. This platform and engine has everything but reach. They have haemorrhaged players. If I can't get an audience on sbox cuz nobody is on it then I've got no choice but to stick it on Steam (or itch). Goes against the motto. If you ever need a reality check please go to https://sboxdb.dev/ Screenshot_20261027_084922_Chrome.jpg 78.42 KB
I don't think you are in it for money (though you did mention the playfund in detail in your original post). So, because if you are just in as a hobbyist who wants share their game with people, a few hundred players to a few thousand players is genuinely a pretty good turnout for an indie game, which is what the platform currently is offering even before it goes free to play and the barrier to entry is removed. If you expected a greater turnout then your game would have to go viral or have a lot of promotion on your end and if it had that success then the hurdles you were concerned over obviously wouldn't stop you from getting your game published on Steam. Additionally, you can just list your game on other platforms like itch.io, which players of smaller less-sucessful indie games are already comfortable using. On top of all this, the publishing directly to Steam thing is still an eventual goal of s&box even if it takes a few more years. So, bluntly, if all of that holds I don't see what your issue is.
edited 26 days ago#10
AReallyLongName XxX
Member
JoinedDec 2022 Posts11 Score670
I don't think you are in it for money (though you did mention the playfund in detail in your original post). So, because if you are just in as a hobbyist who wants share their game with people, a few hundred players to a few thousand players is genuinely a pretty good turnout for an indie game, which is what the platform currently is offering even before it goes free to play and the barrier to entry is removed. If you expected a greater turnout then your game would have to go viral or have a lot of promotion on your end and if it had that success then the hurdles you were concerned over obviously wouldn't stop you from getting your game published on Steam. Additionally, you can just list your game on other platforms like itch.io, which players of smaller less-sucessful indie games are already comfortable using. On top of all this, the publishing directly to Steam thing is still an eventual goal of s&box even if it takes a few more years. So, bluntly, if all of that holds I don't see what your issue is.
Looks like there is no issue after all. Very glad we agree on everything, and also agree that having 0 players and sitting and waiting for them on a dead platform is a worse idea than getting your game on a platform or storefront with players on it. Good luck getting it on itch when you've been instructed not to distribute standalone builds of your project as well. Not sure why you think itch is an exception. Utterly delusional. You can read the below on the wiki.

https://sbox.game/dev/doc/exporting/
SLOW DOWN!!
Member
JoinedJan 2025 Posts40 Score8,036

Very glad we agree on everything that having 0 players and sitting and waiting for them on a dead platform is a worse idea than getting your game on a platform or storefront with players on it. Good luck getting it on itch when you've been instructed not to distribute standalone builds of your project as well. Not sure why you think itch is an exception. Utterly delusional. You can read the below on the wiki. https://sbox.game/dev/doc/exporting/ Screenshot_20261027_102226_Chrome.jpg 601.75 KB    
Ah, I see. At this time apparently you can list it on platforms like itch and just link to the sbox game. Sorry about that, I did mention in my first post I wasn't sure, but I have seen some sbox games listed which is why I said it vaguely to begin with. Regardless, since sbox is going free to play soon anyone who wants to play your game would be able to use sbox for free so there wouldn't be any barrier there. Later, the publishing to Steam without needing explicit approval will still eventually happen. Unless your game is going to take less than a year or two to make and time is urgent for you, I doubt that kind of delay is that big of a deal. Even if it is, porting what you have on top of that development time could take longer unless you're using some, uh, modern automated assistance. Even after releasing your game though, you probably have other games in mind to work on after this and because sbox's workflow is basically the same as any other modern game engine anything you learn should transfer over to the next engine fairly easily.
Separate from that, I don't really understand why you are saying this platform has 0 players. There are in fact games with 10s of thousands to 100s of thousands of unique player. Your indie game probably will not achieve that if it was released directly on Steam. And, I don't know if you have this, but If you already have a following of people interested in your work, since sbox is going free to play and the barrier to play games on the platform is getting removed, there wouldn't be anything stopping players like that from trying your game prior to the eventual publishing feature going live.
If despite all of that the sbox player count is still a concern for you I would think it would be more reasonable to see how things might change after a few months of sbox becoming free to play before committing to anything drastic like porting your game to another platform.
This is just my opinion though. I don't really know why you are being aggressive towards me about this fairly innocent discussion; from my perspective all of this this makes sense especially if money isn't a factor and its not like getting me or you ratioed is going to solve your problems here but idk
AReallyLongName XxX
Member
JoinedDec 2022 Posts11 Score670
Ah, I see. At this time apparently you can list it on platforms like itch and just link to the sbox game. Sorry about that, I did mention in my first post I wasn't sure, but I have seen some sbox games listed which is why I said it vaguely to begin with. Regardless, since sbox is going free to play soon anyone who wants to play your game would be able to use sbox for free so there wouldn't be any barrier there. Later, the publishing to Steam without needing explicit approval will still eventually happen. Unless your game is going to take less than a year or two to make and time is urgent for you, I doubt that kind of delay is that big of a deal. Even if it is, porting what you have on top of that development time could take longer unless you're using some, uh, modern automated assistance. Even after releasing your game though, you probably have other games in mind to work on after this and because sbox's workflow is basically the same as any other modern game engine anything you learn should transfer over to the next engine fairly easily. Separate from that, I don't really understand why you are saying this platform has 0 players. There are in fact games with 10s of thousands to 100s of thousands of unique player. Your indie game probably will not achieve that if it was released directly on Steam. And, I don't know if you have this, but If you already have a following of people interested in your work, since sbox is going free to play and the barrier to play games on the platform is getting removed, there wouldn't be anything stopping players like that from trying your game prior to the eventual publishing feature going live. If despite all of that the sbox player count is still a concern for you I would think it would be more reasonable to see how things might change after a few months of sbox becoming free to play before committing to anything drastic like porting your game to another platform. This is just my opinion though. I don't really know why you are being aggressive towards me about this fairly innocent discussion; from my perspective all of this this makes sense especially if money isn't a factor and its not like getting me or you ratioed is going to solve your problems here but idk

I've provided actual player counts (https://sboxdb.dev/) and the licensing documentation. You're being disingenuous and making stuff up.

The platform struggles to maintain 100 concurrent players, F2P guarantees nothing, standalone publishing has no guaranteed timeline. I'll definitely be watching the F2P launch but I think your expectations need to come down. 

Your "most indie games fail anyway" argument is defeatist and irrelevant.

I'd rather port to another engine and publish on Steam, with a vastly larger potential audience and a clear publishing route, than wait indefinitely for hypothetical improvements. And yeah porting is a ton easier now. 

However if you feel like your games and projects will never see success anyway, it doesn't matter what engine you use because you don't care about success or getting people to play your game, which is the point you're ignoring.
SLOW DOWN!!
Member
JoinedJan 2025 Posts40 Score8,036
I've provided actual player counts (https://sboxdb.dev/) and the licensing documentation. You're being disingenuous and making stuff up. The platform struggles to maintain 100 concurrent players, F2P guarantees nothing, standalone publishing has no guaranteed timeline. I'll definitely be watching the F2P launch but I think your expectations need to come down.  Your "most indie games fail anyway" argument is defeatist and irrelevant. I'd rather port to another engine and publish on Steam, with a vastly larger potential audience and a clear publishing route, than wait indefinitely for hypothetical improvements. And yeah porting is a ton easier now.  However if you feel like your games and projects will never see success anyway, it doesn't matter what engine you use because you don't care about success or getting people to play your game, which is the point you're ignoring.
Yeah I mean I agree right now that the total concurrent player counts at any given time is low, but you should check the daily player counts of some of the top games on the platform (ignoring clickers). They're getting around 10-20 players a day and on the recent free weekend (which had little to no advertising by fp) they were getting a few hundred players each per day.

My honest perspective is that this is a pretty good turnout. If you don't agree then I guess that is mostly where our views actually differ, which is fine, but by all accounts that seems to be the kind of money-irrelevant success you were interested in and its totally accessible on this platform. The way I see it, the only way this would be not sufficient is if you think you are able to make a game that's more polished than the things facepunch is putting up as "recommended" and the platform is too small for your game. ...But even if you did make a game like that, it would certainly be able to clear the checks to be published on Steam so that kind of concern isn't valid. If you had another perspective like "oh I can't actually make something as good as those games, so I need to find another venue with less steep competition", then like idk, I don't find that plausible, just releasing on Steam and its endless torrent of games seems like it would be worse for that. Releasing on Steam with the intention of promoting on another platform seems less relevant at this point as well because, like I mentioned earlier, sbox is going free so there will not be a barrier to use it. And, even if the sbox platform completely dies some day I would expect by the time that happens the legal issues with releasing a standalone would be sorted out. Even if they aren't you would still be able to make the launcher and distribute it anyway... and even if you didn't want to do that... well, let's just be honest, by then the aforementioned methods that make porting a ton easier now will probably be developed enough to make porting your game for Unity a single button click (like it or not).

Also, I am not sure why you are saying I am making things up. I think you might have misinterpreted me saying "unique players" as current players which is a different metric. There are games here with thousands of unique players and some over 100k. Though 100k+ would be phenomenal for an indie game.

Also I want to reiterate, what I am saying here is just my opinion. Am not trying to antagonize or have a flame war here. My intention is just wanting to share my thoughts to be helpful in case there's some things either you or anyone else in your situation hasn't considered and were actually looking for this kind of input. I think what I am suggesting is reasonable and I definitely don't see it as "defeatist". A few thousand players on indie games as polished as the games topping the platform is about what you should be expecting. I see you are reacting to my post with "dumb" amongst other things and I just kind of see that as petty and immature. Like I don't know man, I get that you are going through some stuff, but like if you were already leaving and weren't actually interested in other's takes on this then what is the point of trying to make a dramatic exit while taking shots at strangers? More broadly though, I feel like you might not be entirely honest with what you are saying; you keep talking about success and mentioned royalties and the playfund but have also said you're not doing anything for money. So with that in mind, a few thousand players on a polished indie game is successful and should consider that to be a VERY good result, but I don't think this platform is going to cap you at those levels if you actually made a game that was able to go beyond that; reasonably you should expect they would get you published to Steam in that context.
AReallyLongName XxX
Member
JoinedDec 2022 Posts11 Score670
 What an unusual person 
eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
I think if you look at it as purely a game engine, it's harder to make the case to develop on instead of moving to or sticking with Unity or Unreal currently. Imo, S&Box has some real advantages and novel ideas as a game engine, a platform, and a passionate developer community, but I worry the other things that make S&Box really appealing, are being overlooked. 
Ghostmellow
Member
JoinedFeb 2026 Posts46 Score4,726
eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
defthue
Member
JoinedFeb 2026 Posts23 Score1,425
I am far from being at a point where i can start thinking about a standalone release
but i do understand the confusion about going standalone, there never really has been clear information on what to expect when you do want to go standalone. And after 6000+ hours i can understand the frustration or fear that lingers.
Hopefully facepunch will clear this up sooner rather than later.

I'm curious tho besides the standalone part, you've spent so much time on your games and you say you feel like your in limbo, why haven't you published a demo or just the game to test it out on a smaller playerbase? its a great opportunity to get feedback without being fully committed to it as a final product.
im assuming thats because your not finished with it, which leads me to the question how come your so worried about going standalone before even utilizing the advantages that Sbox does currently offer? if you switch to another engine now, wouldn't that be picking the worst of both worlds because you haven't yet utilized the options that came with the sbox engine and its platform.

and you express concern about after spending 3-4 years you expected more than "send us an email and we'll figure it out", rightfully so, but have you actually emailed them and asked these questions? I have these questions aswell, but haven't taken action directly because i'm just starting the journey that you've been on and those concerns arent as pressing for me just yet ;p


eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
I could drop the facade and be like, hey idiots, have you been this dense this whole time? or just want to keep clinging on the sinking band wagon? But, I'll leave my opinions here for the moment and keep it business friendly :) 
defthue
Member
JoinedFeb 2026 Posts23 Score1,425
  • acts like he knows better
  • doesnt actually offer any answers
  • says he wont do something, yet does it immediately after in an aggressive way
  • adds another comment contradicting himself

    I rate this ragebait, 6/10
    I could drop the facade and be like, hey idiots, have you been this dense this whole time? or just want to keep clinging on the sinking band wagon? But, I'll leave my opinions here for the moment and keep it business friendly :) 
eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
haha, it's not so much rage bait as I am just lighting a fire ;) But, I think you are allowed to be a little emotional in stating your case. I think you are missing, the point a little bit, though. The problem is that s&box should be going upward, not downward and it doesn't seem like it's just a dip, imo as well. Hopefully it will regain traction, though! I just feel like the morale is very low and no one is really addressing that and the ones who try get told the equivalent of "just go touch grass bro." 
DerrikCreates
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts8 Score585
from reading and talking with FP people, standalone exporting will be fixed. IMO the problem is valve being a bitch and not letting anyone freely publish. The frustration you feel at facepunch should be directed at valve, since people are already forking and removing source 2.

to be it seems clear valve are the one being difficult. If we want s&box to stand next to unity and godot as a "real" engine we se should be calling for facepunch to cut source 2 and escape valves BS.

eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
I'm sure it will eventually work itself out! :D Just hope, they are learning as they go, though! ;) Cause damn, I am such an optimist, but even I have been running on fumes for well a couple years now looking back... I don't blame how OP feels about the current state of things... But either way, I will always root for Facepunch and their new baby :D 
Doctor
Member
JoinedJan 2025 Posts52 Score6,645
i completely agree.
I think I've got about 6000-6500 hours in the engine. It's not an accurate reflection of what I should have achieved but it was a decent run and I learned a lot anyway.  I've got a few serious long term projects, one of which is a boomer shooter that has been in development since about 2022-2023. I chose s&box because it was new back then, was changing a lot, and it was exciting. And I was familiar with Source.  I have made some serious progress on my projects lately and I can see them being positioned on a storefront like Steam. That has led to the feeling of sunk-cost fallacy and I'm starting to feel a bit dumb.  There are some things on my mind: 1) The platform is going nowhere, regardless of what I build. I'm not too fussed about this because it's clear the platform is a structure for rapidly-prototyped minigames, easy to jump in and out of. This isn't the reason I got involved and I just want to clarify that I always got into this engine as a way to make my own long-term larger projects that I could publish on Steam. So my projects are not really suited for this kind of platform or audience anyway - even if it is failing. But still, it definitely doesn't look good, and takes a lot of confidence away that I have in the company building all this.  2) There is still no concrete official statement about self-publishing. This is the main reason my review on Steam switched over from recommended to not recommended. This really needs to be clarified and is the reason I'm making this last-ditch post to bitch about it. When can we expect an official statement that isn't "ask us first"? Really with the way the platform is headed I think focusing on engine use and licencing is FP's best bet. If you are serious about opening this up, everybody needs to know where they stand.  3) Games are now greenlit before entering the playfund. This is a blessing and a curse. I'm already very aware of the nepotism that is in this community and the favouring of close mates or community members is not unheard of. But I also think that's fairly normal in these kinds of smaller communities. Regardless there is no clear process established yet that goes over any of these to instill confidence against inherent bias. There's also no clear rules on what's allowed and what isn't. It all seems discretionary. Does Facepunch handle the greenlight decision? Is it handled by the community? Votes? We all saw how that worked with the jam.  4) For exporting your game, this discretion goes even further. Firstly, you have to contact garry via email to submit your game that you already paid to put up on Steam. Then, they have to contact Valve to approve the licence. This seems fairly reasonable (albeit backwards, shouldn't you approve before I pay to stick it on Steam?) until you realise that the games currently on Steam made in s&box are still waiting for release or greenlight with no movement there. Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong, but I cannot find any information on what kind of response these teams have had. It all seems like radio silence or ambiguity. Are there any movements there? Does anybody know what is or isn't allowed? What is the process involved and is there a checklist? 5) The engine is perpetually touted as "royalty free" which is really redundant if you've got extra hoops to jump through to get your game on Steam. I'd rather pay you royalties than have the ambiguity while I'm working. Cross my toes and hope it gets approved? Why would I do that?  To be clear I have never been a victim of game-breaking updates or API changes. I've always kept my code fairly agnostic and never really tried to do overly weird shit with the engine. So I'm not complaining about that. I'm also not bothered about politics or discourse. I'm just wondering why people who are making larger games with small teams shouldn't jump ship to another engine. What motivation is there to stick around exactly? I'm putting all this work in but there's no guarantee a) it'd be greenlit and b) I'd get to publish on Steam. This makes larger projects untenable, but now I'm in too deep, because I thought after 3-4 years you'd have something more than "send us an email and we'll figure it out".  Maybe I'm overthinking this and should just start porting over to Unity anyway. I'm writing this out because it's frustrating. But something's gotta give. I'm putting way too many hours into something that looks like it's falling to bits. If you gave us actual steps and processes, requirements, or things that are or aren't allowed, maybe I wouldn't be so keen to jump ship, but it all looks so grim, and with Unity 7 round the corner, what's the point? Basically I feel like I'm stuck in Limbo and I've also read the same frustrations elsewhere. Am I in the minority? 
people
Log in to reply
You can't reply if you're not logged in. That would be crazy.