The complete switch to Steam Workshop in the future seems like a very strange and unexpected decision to me. I don't follow Facepunch's promises or announcements very closely, but this genuinely caught me off guard and makes me sad. I knew work was being done on Steam Workshop "support," but completely replacing asset.party is a huge step backward. Maybe you mentioned somewhere that you wanted to abandon the current system in favor of an older one, but the roadmap doesn't say a word about that, only "support."
But I can live with that, even though we're losing many of asset.party's advantages and its future potential. Sure, we're getting some benefits in return, but in my opinion the downsides outweigh the upsides. Even if we move addons and other content to Steam Workshop, why move games there too? I don't know how much control you have over the Workshop, but I don't want one giant dumping ground where games, models, scripts, and Sandbox dupes are all mixed together under a shared rating system. What about the rating system we already have? Reviews? Game tags? Organizations? Everything that had already been built and was working? If the Workshop can't provide enough functionality to separate AI slop and clickers from actual games, generate recommendations, highlight games with the highest player counts, games gaining popularity, or trending games, without mixing them in with unrelated things like Sandbox dupes or popular models, then the Workshop really will turn into a junkyard. All the filtering will end up happening on the s&box backend, and we'll be subscribing to games from inside the game itself. But then what's the point of the Workshop if nobody actually uses it? Nostalgia for the old days and the ability to preload content without launching the game?
And honestly, I don't really understand the appeal of downloading content without launching the game. Most GMod players play on servers, and there isn't really any preloading there. I know some servers create their own content packs in the Workshop that you can download ahead of time to join faster, but in most cases players simply click on a server and start downloading whatever content they need. I don't know how things work now, but the last time I played GMod was, I think, around 2020, and servers commonly used a system where you could join as quickly as possible and download the necessary content while already playing. Those walking "ERROR" signs would gradually turn into actual models right before your eyes. Isn't that exactly the kind of streaming system we're losing?
I have a feeling that sooner or later, a similar addon will appear on the platform, or Facepunch will implement such a system themselves in response to player requests. That would be funny.
What upsets me most is that this decision seems to be about improving the game's reputation among people who aren't going to play it. Steam Workshop is mainly what GMod players have been asking for, because they don't want to bother learning a more promising system. They wanted GMod 2 at release, but the game was in very rough shape at launch: poor performance, a lack of content, lots of AI slop, $20 per copy, paid skins, a completely empty Sandbox mode, no content from Source 1 and Source 2 games, and much more. And they were understandably unwilling to figure out asset.party, because their thinking was basically, "Why bother putting effort into learning this when everything else is so poorly done? That must mean asset.party is bad too. I want things back the way they used to be, all through Steam Workshop!" Even now, more than six months later, many things have improved, but people still remember asset.party as garbage, even though it isn't. What really disappoints me is that, after all the changes Facepunch has made, only a minority of the people who demanded them will probably come back to s&box. Sandbox still has very little content, and at this point it will probably never match GMod in sheer volume of content. It would take years and years to catch up. So current and future developers are losing a really good, forward-looking system for the sake of people who won't even play the game, or, if they do, they'll only show up years later, once the game has enough content to compete with GMod.
Finally, here's how I imagined Steam Workshop "support" would work. I thought game developers would be able to choose whether to add Workshop support to their games, or that the Workshop would only be used for Sandbox mode, with Sandbox itself being the flagship mode of the platform, not buried somewhere among other games, but pinned right on the main menu. I think this would have satisfied everyone, or at least most people. I supported bringing Steam Workshop in as a kind of marketing move, saying, "We listen to what you want and give you what you're asking for," while still keeping asset.party as an alternative, so people could compare their experiences with Steam Workshop and asset.party and gradually get to know the more advanced system. Ultimately, the goal would be for players to want to use asset.party themselves, to recognize how good it is and what advantages it offers! In a way, it would win the approval of both veteran developers and new players!
This ended up being a lot longer than I expected. I was just putting my thoughts into words, so I hope I didn't go off on too many tangents and managed to express myself clearly enough!