Steam Workshop for Games

Started by devultj · 21 days ago · 58 replies · 5,628 views

s314noza
Member
JoinedDec 2024 Posts2 Score2,781
I get maps and mods, but entire games? Why?
-vx
Member
JoinedFeb 2023 Posts5 Score1,605
I don't like how it doesn't merge favorites/likes/reviews from asset.party and Steam Workshop. Now my game is back to square one (0 likes, 0 favorites when clicking on the game in S&box itself), which makes me feel very iffy about discoverability :/
Stayfin
Member
JoinedNov 2022 Posts5 Score4,570
Bummer I kind of liked the layout of asset.party. Hopefully it's flexible enough for all the different types of content in s&box
Cyber Agent
Member
JoinedJul 2022 Posts1 Score4,465
I think this is a mistake to go this route for games. downloading them is better and it keeps them updates yes, but I believe that having access to asset party and uploading them that way was superior. I think this leans a bit too much into the gmod side, and if you guys really are going for an improved "gmod 2" experience, then mods and addons should be on the workshop for the sandbox mode, but games should stay on asset party. 

I don't really see any discourse being that games are not on workshop, I believe that people coming in from gmod would not care about that, they would care if mods and addons were, but i think entire games should remain as they are. 

there has to be a middle ground here, and believe this leans to much into the already existent. 

I don't know, but the general discourse I've seen has been player models, mounts, and lack of a solid sandbox mode. games themselves, their only real discourse has been not wanting to see slop. 

They also did not enjoy micro transactions, but i believe that can be alleviated by having all the other concerns heavily addressed. 

I could be wrong though, but this is my opinion idk i guess you can cancel me for it i guess idkk.....

K3rhos
Member
JoinedJul 2023 Posts59 Score680
The worst possible decision ever taken by Facepunch, I mean I'm okay with maps and addons on the steam workshop but not games, this is just crap, now we (devs) have to reupload the WHOLE entire game to the steamworkshop everytime we make an update, instead of just sending the new files. On top of that dedup isn't supported, which means we will redownload the same assets multiple times for different games.

Nope there is not a single positive things about this decision, apart to please to the GMOD fanboys who still don't understand that S&box workshop is just infinitely better in every SINGLE way possible.

I pray for this change to be reverted.
Қatka ♥
Member
JoinedMay 2021 Posts5 Score4,503
I understand the change if the players actually pushed for this, but I don't think they really did?

I am speaking for myself, but all I wanted was a way to pre-load shit (aka subscribe to an addon/mod/map/game whatever you want to call it) and then just play the game without waiting for shit to constantly download (you can also play offline if for some reason your internet decides to fuck off).

And I believe this is what the people complaining about the current way games and Sandbox addons worked have a problem with. It was not necessary to move to the Steam Workshop, just have the same system for game addons like it is in other games that utilize the Steam Workshop, but use the current cloud.
edited 20 days ago#37
Bedhead
Member
JoinedMar 2026 Posts1 Score1,620
is the vision for the new ideal future to have the player subscribe to addons to be able to access the majority of the platform's content (games, maps, and etc), or is the ideal future for the platform to be functionally the same as it's been since launch, but now using the steam workshop as a backend instead of an in-house one?

if it's the former (i.e. being more like gmod) then i gotta ask, what's the point? like genuinely what would the point be aside from appealing to nostalgia? because other than that, it seems like a huge step backwards to the platform

the entire appeal of this since launch has been the ability to play games with one click, or spawn stuff in with one click, but without that it's just a worse gmod on the sandbox end since it has less stuff and is arguably less polished AND NOW is more dated since i have to mod stuff in instead of just loading it in, and a worse "discovery page" on the platform end since there's more of a barrier between the player and the game, which makes me really wonder what makes the steam workshop so good that the game had to switch directions entirely and arguably go backwards instead of just improving the in-house tools. Like at that point, why would i try to convince my friends to play the sandbox mode in this instead of gmod? or why would i say "hey i know you played almost this exact thing on roblox, but you should download s&box and then MOD IN a very similar game instead of just opening roblox and clicking on the game"? because at least before it had the draw of being a modernized gmod instead of just a modern gmod

i'm kinda disappointed by the potential new direction, i paid for s&box, not gmod 2

& EVEN IF the goal is to go towards the ladder direction out of the two i described, and i just wasted time with the last paragraph, then that needs to be made way more clear, because a large group of people think the opposite

TL;DR most of the fair first impressions had the criticism that the platform was unfinished, not that that it wasn't like gmod (*in terms of the workshop stuff), NO ONE who genuinely met the idea where it was at had the takeaway of "oh i wish i had to download stuff from the steam workshop instead", so PLEASE stop appealing to the old chuds who just whine about change, and try to look for the actual critiques

like i said, i paid for s&box, not gmod 2, so STOP LISTENING TO THE PEOPLE WHO JUST WANT IT TO BE GMOD 2, you made it clear from the start that s&box wasn't that, so please don't betray the people who bought s&box for s&box, because that's what this new update looks to do
Mister Generic
Member
JoinedOct 2021 Posts11 Score965
I'm kinda lost cuz you literally can see every gamemodes that you just click in and download the content when you join a server on the server browser on Gmod so what is the need to replace the old flow of discovering games when it's essentially just the same thing as that but with an algorithm pushing different games.

The offline and up to date thing seems nice but you can just essentially build that into the same system with like a favourite button which can also be used for filtering menus

edited 20 days ago#39
kitsupanic
Member
JoinedJul 2026 Posts5 Score405
Step 1 - shadowban all slop games like idles or clickers
Step 2 - move to another system so devs will upload only "good games" from now on

Ah yes, it is a precise master plan i see
Two birds with one stone
brady
Member
JoinedJul 2024 Posts1 Score60
This just does not make any sense to me at all, are you guys drowning in storage costs or what
Fritzkier
Member
JoinedJun 2023 Posts2 Score560
Why not integrate both? People who want to play and don't care with development they can use steam workshop, while people who want to build a game in s&box they can use asset.party like unity asset store. Using only steam workshop seems backward to me...
thatcher
Member
JoinedNov 2022 Posts1 Score150
Please keep asset.party while also allowing for games to be downloaded from workshop
edited 19 days ago#43
ChronicWishlister
Member
JoinedMay 2026 Posts17 Score2,325

Lets be honest:

The current system with games, reviews, and ratings has been completely corrupted by *some* members within the community. Enough so to hurt the platform as a whole.

Go ahead and thumb through some two-star games and compare them to Four Star games. It's not accurate. They don't actually reflect such differences in gameplay. It's not Merit based. It's a popularity contest where people with duplicate accounts or friends in the community get flooded with positives While others can make a good, polished gameplay experience and get shafted.

Face punch put its trust in good faith toward the community, and they and other well-meaning members got the shaft.


And those who participate in this know who they are. Take some accountability. The play fund completely corrupted huge portions of people to the point of bashing and down voting completely playable experiences, all because they thought they could earn a nickel. Weak characters corrupt the system.


P.S. - I am glad they are revitalizing the Garry's Mod clone, but unfortunately you'll see thay you'll never be able to please some people.

Trust your instincts, FacePunch. Success is never a straight line. I have faith that you'll figure this all out, and you'll have my support.

A lot of the hate filled reviews came from people who misunderstood the meaning of the word "Spiritual Successor". Go check out games from the Dreams platform on PS4. It's filled with what those haters within this community would call AI slop, except there was no AI for the whole thing. This AI Witch Hunt is a social narrative and construct based out of fear and negativity. AI is a tool which some use as an excuse to release their own inner-demons. I have no problem with categorizing games that use AI assets, but they certainly don't deserve half of the hate that they've generated when used by solo or new Developers as they continue to build and refine their skillsets. Or some of the users just want to direct their own game experience solo. Haters need to chill. Maybe somebody wants to create a card battling game but they can't draw like the artists at blizzard. Should they not be allowed to make a game without getting dumped on?

 I don't use AI models animations or anything else that can be avoided. But I don't hate that those that do, or use free asset packs, because I'm not a hater. The platform attracts people who never made a game before. Let them grow without all the hate. Thats *my* ideal for fostering a better platform.
Garion, Arbiter of the Head
Member
JoinedJun 2024 Posts1 Score585
i absolutely agree with that, it would be cool if some games could have workshop compatablity "mainly sandbox mode" but having the entire games be in workshop just doesn't feel right
i think this is the wrong decision. people are wanting steam workshop for mods/sandbox mode not the entire game 
edited 19 days ago#45
eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
I kind of think the rating system was premature... I still kind of think of s&box as a sort of, kind of... incubator/accelerator for aspiring game devs (or game dev  adjacent) who want to do "shit" "professionally", but that is just me 
Ravsee
Member
JoinedApr 2026 Posts17 Score740
Lets be honest: The current system with games, reviews, and ratings has been completely corrupted by *some* members within the community. Enough so to hurt the platform as a whole. Go ahead and thumb through some two-star games and compare them to Four Star games. It's not accurate. They don't actually reflect such differences in gameplay. It's not Merit based. It's a popularity contest where people with duplicate accounts or friends in the community get flooded with positives While others can make a good, polished gameplay experience and get shafted. Face punch put its trust in good faith toward the community, and they and other well-meaning members got the shaft. And those who participate in this know who they are. Take some accountability. The play fund completely corrupted huge portions of people to the point of bashing and down voting completely playable experiences, all because they thought they could earn a nickel. Weak characters corrupt the system. P.S. - I am glad they are revitalizing the Garry's Mod clone, but unfortunately you'll see thay you'll never be able to please some people. Trust your instincts, FacePunch. Success is never a straight line. I have faith that you'll figure this all out, and you'll have my support. A lot of the hate filled reviews came from people who misunderstood the meaning of the word "Spiritual Successor". Go check out games from the Dreams platform on PS4. It's filled with what those haters within this community would call AI slop, except there was no AI for the whole thing. This AI Witch Hunt is a social narrative and construct based out of fear and negativity. AI is a tool which some use as an excuse to release their own inner-demons. I have no problem with categorizing games that use AI assets, but they certainly don't deserve half of the hate that they've generated when used by solo or new Developers as they continue to build and refine their skillsets. Or some of the users just want to direct their own game experience solo. Haters need to chill. Maybe somebody wants to create a card battling game but they can't draw like the artists at blizzard. Should they not be allowed to make a game without getting dumped on?  I don't use AI models animations or anything else that can be avoided. But I don't hate that those that do, or use free asset packs, because I'm not a hater. The platform attracts people who never made a game before. Let them grow without all the hate. Thats *my* ideal for fostering a better platform.
The current situation is exactly like this: the entire system—both its positive and negative aspects—has become completely corrupted. Someone who once developed games and produced a decent title in their own time comes along, spends all of 30 seconds on my game, and leaves a negative review. As it happens, while checking my statistics, I notice that along with this review, I’ve also received six new dislikes. If our content is genuinely bad, then so be it—we’ll just make something better. But to disparage someone else’s work simply because one’s own popularity has faded, or out of pure jealousy—people who do this are truly pathetic individuals.
narexa
Member
JoinedApr 2023 Posts23 Score16,789
Huuuh I don't think it should be for entire games 
Ravsee
Member
JoinedApr 2026 Posts17 Score740
These are exactly the types of people I’m referring to—let no one else take this personally. This individual is truly pathetic, and by responding, they’re essentially admitting that they are, in fact, that pathetic person. I didn’t say anything to the person who commented based on their actual gameplay, but this—this is pure malice. I wish you the best of luck with the helicopter game you’re working on; I hope you manage to create something great.
Brassx
Member
JoinedMay 2021 Posts10 Score5
I think it's great you're listening to feedback and adjusting, but I personally think its a bit too hasty for something like this.  I don't think you should just toss your guys whole vision and hard work with asset.party (in my opinion).

Steamworkshop for full on games would be a miss for me, I simply would not want my games hosted on the steamworkshop. That said, I wouldn't mind having support for steamworkshop for mods for my OWN games within s&box that I make (with an API that I choose to implement into my own game to support mods). I think that's ultimately what most players want. They would want workshop for mods to existing games on S&box, not for like actual games.  The people you are catering to with this change probably aren't thinking about games they're thinking about mods & maps.  They just want to sub to 100 addons and spawn in sandbox mode with it all and create chaos.
Fantastic
Member
JoinedJan 2023 Posts24 Score19,049
I know people have been very prescriptive about their belief that sbox should use the steam workshop but I don't know if this is what they meant, and I don't think it's helpful.
The only thing that seems like a positive is being able to subscribe to games in order to auto-download updates and save time ingame.
Besides that, it seems like nothing but downsides.

Sorry about Ravsee spamming the thread, I played his game since he was claiming people were unfairly leaving him bad reviews - and it was slop, big surprise! - so I left a bad review and he decided to come back to complain about it more.
Whatever man. Stuff made by an AI agent shouldn't be in the playfund or even, preferably, on the platform at all, and that's not an opinion I'll change any time soon. But that doesn't have much relevance to this discussion, does it?
SLOW DOWN!!
Member
JoinedJan 2025 Posts39 Score8,036
These are exactly the types of people I’m referring to—let no one else take this personally. This individual is truly pathetic, and by responding, they’re essentially admitting that they are, in fact, that pathetic person. I didn’t say anything to the person who commented based on their actual gameplay, but this—this is pure malice. I wish you the best of luck with the helicopter game you’re working on; I hope you manage to create something great. pathetic.png 32.68 KB
Hey man don't let people like that bother you. Your game has over 10,000 hours of playtime, is gets mostly postive feedback, and looks good. This many players is obviously a good performance for this platform. If you post something that has over 800 people interacting with it a few people who hate you is inevitable. Your game will continue to be promoted on sbox regardless.

Personally your game is on my backlog of sbox games I'm planning on trying and I will probably play it this weekend. 👍
edited 19 days ago#52
Ravsee
Member
JoinedApr 2026 Posts17 Score740
I know people have been very prescriptive about their belief that sbox should use the steam workshop but I don't know if this is what they meant, and I don't think it's helpful. The only thing that seems like a positive is being able to subscribe to games in order to auto-download updates and save time ingame. Besides that, it seems like nothing but downsides. Sorry about Ravsee spamming the thread, I played his game since he was claiming people were unfairly leaving him bad reviews - and it was slop, big surprise! - so I left a bad review and he decided to come back to complain about it more. Whatever man. Stuff made by an AI agent shouldn't be in the playfund or even, preferably, on the platform at all, and that's not an opinion I'll change any time soon. But that doesn't have much relevance to this discussion, does it?
There’s no need to clutter the forum with spam. Thanks a lot for your comment! :D 
edited:
Hey man don't let people like that bother you. Your game has over 10,000 hours of playtime, is gets mostly postive feedback, and looks good. This many players is obviously a good performance for this platform. If you post something that has over 800 people interacting with it a few people who hate you is inevitable. Your game will continue to be promoted on sbox regardless. Personally your game is on my backlog of sbox games I'm planning on trying and I will probably play it this weekend. 👍
Thanks a lot, my friend. The issue I wanted to bring up already played out here, so there’s no need to write any more about it. I’d appreciate it if you could share any feedback—good or bad—on how things could be improved; I want to develop a game that both I and the players will enjoy. And if anyone thinks that negative comments like these will discourage me, they’ll have to try a lot harder!
KapiDranik
Member
JoinedJun 2023 Posts7 Score1,390
What if we gave players the option to download games, for faster loading or offline play, instead of forcing them to subscribe to those games?
Tomkha
Member
JoinedFeb 2025 Posts7 Score165
I think one of the main pain points of gmod I ever had was just the sheer amount of workshop mods you had to be subscribed to and the duration of downloads for everyone involved. I see that the workshop could work fine for stuff like maps, but for games I feel like it isn't a great fit.
SavageNPsycho
Member
JoinedApr 2026 Posts73 Score7,880
Can you explain What the steam workshop even is?  
eXodos
Member
JoinedAug 2022 Posts41 Score3,010
It's a workshop on Steam idiot! Damn! How can you not know that! (Sorry, I am joking) 
Braanflakes
Member
JoinedApr 2023 Posts4 Score345
I was a big fan of asset.party, but we'll see how this goes. I just published for the first time since the workshop change and it was a fairly smooth process. This really feels like a departure away from what I thought s&box was going to be and it's starting to just feel like Garry's Mod 2, in a bad way.
Eridor
Member
JoinedMar 2023 Posts1 Score160
The complete switch to Steam Workshop in the future seems like a very strange and unexpected decision to me. I don't follow Facepunch's promises or announcements very closely, but this genuinely caught me off guard and makes me sad. I knew work was being done on Steam Workshop "support," but completely replacing asset.party is a huge step backward. Maybe you mentioned somewhere that you wanted to abandon the current system in favor of an older one, but the roadmap doesn't say a word about that, only "support."

But I can live with that, even though we're losing many of asset.party's advantages and its future potential. Sure, we're getting some benefits in return, but in my opinion the downsides outweigh the upsides. Even if we move addons and other content to Steam Workshop, why move games there too? I don't know how much control you have over the Workshop, but I don't want one giant dumping ground where games, models, scripts, and Sandbox dupes are all mixed together under a shared rating system. What about the rating system we already have? Reviews? Game tags? Organizations? Everything that had already been built and was working? If the Workshop can't provide enough functionality to separate AI slop and clickers from actual games, generate recommendations, highlight games with the highest player counts, games gaining popularity, or trending games, without mixing them in with unrelated things like Sandbox dupes or popular models, then the Workshop really will turn into a junkyard. All the filtering will end up happening on the s&box backend, and we'll be subscribing to games from inside the game itself. But then what's the point of the Workshop if nobody actually uses it? Nostalgia for the old days and the ability to preload content without launching the game?
And honestly, I don't really understand the appeal of downloading content without launching the game. Most GMod players play on servers, and there isn't really any preloading there. I know some servers create their own content packs in the Workshop that you can download ahead of time to join faster, but in most cases players simply click on a server and start downloading whatever content they need. I don't know how things work now, but the last time I played GMod was, I think, around 2020, and servers commonly used a system where you could join as quickly as possible and download the necessary content while already playing. Those walking "ERROR" signs would gradually turn into actual models right before your eyes. Isn't that exactly the kind of streaming system we're losing?

I have a feeling that sooner or later, a similar addon will appear on the platform, or Facepunch will implement such a system themselves in response to player requests. That would be funny.

What upsets me most is that this decision seems to be about improving the game's reputation among people who aren't going to play it. Steam Workshop is mainly what GMod players have been asking for, because they don't want to bother learning a more promising system. They wanted GMod 2 at release, but the game was in very rough shape at launch: poor performance, a lack of content, lots of AI slop, $20 per copy, paid skins, a completely empty Sandbox mode, no content from Source 1 and Source 2 games, and much more. And they were understandably unwilling to figure out asset.party, because their thinking was basically, "Why bother putting effort into learning this when everything else is so poorly done? That must mean asset.party is bad too. I want things back the way they used to be, all through Steam Workshop!" Even now, more than six months later, many things have improved, but people still remember asset.party as garbage, even though it isn't. What really disappoints me is that, after all the changes Facepunch has made, only a minority of the people who demanded them will probably come back to s&box. Sandbox still has very little content, and at this point it will probably never match GMod in sheer volume of content. It would take years and years to catch up. So current and future developers are losing a really good, forward-looking system for the sake of people who won't even play the game, or, if they do, they'll only show up years later, once the game has enough content to compete with GMod.

Finally, here's how I imagined Steam Workshop "support" would work. I thought game developers would be able to choose whether to add Workshop support to their games, or that the Workshop would only be used for Sandbox mode, with Sandbox itself being the flagship mode of the platform, not buried somewhere among other games, but pinned right on the main menu. I think this would have satisfied everyone, or at least most people. I supported bringing Steam Workshop in as a kind of marketing move, saying, "We listen to what you want and give you what you're asking for," while still keeping asset.party as an alternative, so people could compare their experiences with Steam Workshop and asset.party and gradually get to know the more advanced system. Ultimately, the goal would be for players to want to use asset.party themselves, to recognize how good it is and what advantages it offers! In a way, it would win the approval of both veteran developers and new players!

This ended up being a lot longer than I expected. I was just putting my thoughts into words, so I hope I didn't go off on too many tangents and managed to express myself clearly enough! 
TheDoomLordd
Member
JoinedSep 2025 Posts16 Score955
Why not just use the workshop as the backend storage and just use the in-game browser? I'm not well versed in how Steam handles such things, just my thoughts
people
Log in to reply
You can't reply if you're not logged in. That would be crazy.